Medical diagnoses of all kinds have expanded over the last years as science gained new knowledge, Lieberman argued, pointing out that in the s, there were only two mental health diagnoses: idiocy and insanity. The new volume recognizes those advances. That can lead to over-diagnosis and, worse, overtreatment.
I would recommend PIMSY to anyone looking for a good EMR company that will help you implement its program and help you with any questions you have along the way. Need Support? Free Demo Quote The author prefers, "with no apology," to idiosyncratically diagnose schizoaffective disorder for drug-taking young patients with BD than use the DSM diagnosis of superimposed drug-induced psychosis or BD with psychotic features. Surely having each clinician creatively adopt their own definitions is no solution and would inevitably lead to a diagnostic Tower of Babel.
Although the definition of schizoaffective disorder has been recognized as problematic since DSM-III , the availability of standard diagnostic criteria facilitates much-needed research. The author argues that because the DSM has no clinical value and, in fact, is detrimental to the practice of psychiatry , it should be abandoned.
While we agree that DSM is far from perfect, we strongly disagree with this assertion. One of the most important goals of the DSM-IV is to facilitate communication among mental health care professionals, between mental health care providers and health care administrators, and between mental health care professionals and the public at large. The DSM-IV categories provide a convenient shorthand for describing an individual's symptomatic presentation. When referring a patient to a colleague, saying that "this patient has major depressive disorder" communicates a plethora of important clinical information, including the fact that the patient has either depressed mood or pervasive loss of interest, has a number of other symptoms that cluster with depressed mood e.
In addition, the term major depressive disorder indicates that the clinician has considered and eliminated a number of important disorders in the differential diagnosis, including BD, schizophrenia and schizoaffective disorder, substance-induced mood disorder, and mood disorder due to a medical condition.
Furthermore, by using this term, one can communicate the range of treatments that may be expected to work, as well as expectations about possible future outcomes e. Of course, there are many clinically important aspects of the patient that are not captured by this label, including the psychosocial context in which the depression developed, psychodynamic factors that might be perpetuating the depression and many others. We believe that most mental health care professionals can appreciate this main limitation of the DSM system, namely, that the DSM diagnosis provides only a part of the story.
The point article also criticizes the DSM convention of favoring the assignment of a number of DSM diagnoses to describe complex clinical presentations. This convention allows for the communication of the maximum amount of clinical information without forcing the clinician to make an ill-informed judgment about underlying etiology for which there is little or no evidence. Take, for example, a young female patient who drinks heavily, has severe recurrent depressive episodes, binges and purges, and has panic attacks.
Following the DSM convention, the clinician may choose to assign up to four different diagnoses in order to communicate the various foci of treatment: alcohol abuse, recurrent major depressive disorder, bulimia nervosa and panic disorder.
We believe that clinicians are sophisticated enough to recognize that the DSM is not asserting that the patient has four separate pathological processes.
Most likely, there are one or two underlying processes that are being expressed in a complex way. Unfortunately, given the current limitations in our understanding of psychiatric disorders, it would be total speculation to assign a single diagnosis to this patient.
Which one would you choose--the alcohol use disorder? The mood disorder? That said, determining an accurate diagnosis is the first step toward being able to appropriately treat any medical condition, and mental disorders are no exception.
DSM—5 will also be helpful in measuring the effectiveness of treatment, as dimensional assessments will assist clinicians in assessing changes in severity levels as a response to treatment. Why was the traditional Roman numeral dropped from DSM? Since the research base of mental disorders is evolving at different rates for different disorders, diagnostic guidelines will not be tied to a static publication date but rather to scientific advances.
These incremental updates will be identified with decimals, i. When can DSM—5 be used for insurance purposes? However, the change in format from a multi-axial system in DSM-IV-TR may result in a brief delay while insurance companies update their claim forms and reporting procedures to accommodate DSM—5 changes. DSM—5 contains the most up-to-date criteria for diagnosing mental disorders, along with extensive descriptive text, providing a common language for clinicians to communicate about their patients.
The ICD contains the code numbers used in DSM—5 and all of medicine, needed for insurance reimbursement and for monitoring of morbidity and mortality statistics by national and international health agencies. How much did it cost to produce DSM—5? All of these funds came from APA's reserves and the association received no commercial or government funding for the development of DSM—5.
APA is a non-profit organization representing psychiatrists and sees DSM—5 as an investment in the future of mental health allowing for more precise identification of mental disorders as well as facilitating new research. How can I learn more about DSM—5? Buy Now. Shop the DSM—5 Collection.
0コメント